Ron Simon

Curator, Television and Radio

August 13, 2008

Man on Wire, Not Video

by Ron Simon

You have probably read the glowing reviews for the new documentary Man on Wire. It truly is a spellbinding portrait of the Philippe Petit, the man who "danced" between the Twin Towers, 1350 feet above Manhattan, on August 7, 1974. Director James March is consumed by the process, constructing his documentary as an elaborate heist film.

We experience almost minute by minute how Petit and his band of crazed conspirators planned and executed his death-defying feat, from surreptitiously entering the World Trade Center to avoiding law enforcement throughout the building. The meticulous preparation recalls the daring of Steve McQueen in The Thomas Crown Affair; artistry of any kind is always in the details. We also see plenty of footage of the younger Petit practicing the art of tight rope walking in rural France, with dreams of conquering the emptiness between the world's then two largest structures. Sir Edmund Hillary was obsessed with climbing the 29,029 feet of Mount Everest; for six years Petit focused on the 140 feet between the Tower One and Two.

You would think that the big payoff to this "artistic crime of the 20th century" would be stunning video from all angles of the forty-five minutes that Petit floated between the Towers. Here is the spoiler that few have noticed: there is little motion picture footage of Petit in glorious mid-air. Still cameras captured Petit thrillingly suspended above the city, but we don't see him move in space. The time is 1974, just before the videocassette revolution, which ushered in a new consciousness of media documentation.  Below spectators just watched, having no idea in a few years that they would be generating their own video, first with VHS tape and then with digital cell phones. Electronic news gathering (ENG), with its instantaneous microwave coverage, was in its infancy with many local stations still using the much more cumbersome newsfilm technology.  And, Petit himself, unlike other performance artist of the time, was not insistent on recording his amazing feat for auxiliary markets; for this Frenchman it was a "mythological journey."

But yet the still photographs are more awe-inspiring than any cinematic montage or CGI recreation. Petit is our flesh-and-blood superhero, a Spiderman levitating 110 stories above our mortal condition. His odyssey was a series of moments, where "1/2 millimeter mistake or 1/4 second of distraction" would lead to a gruesome plunge. Marsh underscores Petit's aerial skill with the minimalist strands of Erik Satie, making his achievement feel for the ages. Petit aspired to "the miracle of beauty that talks not so much to our senses, but to our inner heart." In this documentary our senses are not distracted by quick cuts and tracking shots; we contemplate the deeper meanings in the stillness of the image, an exhilarating confirmation of modernism's maxim Less is More. Take a look at the documentary's trailer, frenzied like all promotion, until you get to the resonant pictures. Will the solitary photograph ever speak so eloquently again to us in this media saturated world?

Add a Comment

Join The Conversation

  • Thanks for your comment. I hope that everyone will seek out this awe-inspiring documentary when it becomes available on DVD.


    Ron, October 16, 2008 at 10:24 am

  • I agree. The beautiful and timeless photos of Philippe between the two towers was much more moving than seeing quick footage. And I felt like I saw it more as he might, in a kind of slow motion. It was a very good film and he is an amazing and amazingly focused person.


    hiho, October 13, 2008 at 1:32 pm

Please log in to comment.

About

Ron Simon

Curator, Television and Radio

Subscribe

Ron Simon has been a curator at The Paley Center for Media since the early 1980s. He is also an adjunct associate professor at Columbia University, New York University, and Hunter College, where he teaches courses on the history of media. Simon has written for many publications, including The Encyclopedia of Television and Thinking Outside of the Box, as well as serving as host and creative consultant of the CD-ROM Total Television. A member of the editorial board of Television Quarterly, and a judge on the George Foster Peabody committee, Simon has lectured at museums and educational institutions throughout the world. Among the numerous exhibitions he has curated are The Television of Dennis Potter; Witness to History; Jack Benny: The Television and Radio Work; and Worlds Without End: The Art and History of the Soap Opera. He also discovered such lost programs as the live Honeymooners and the only video performance of the Rat Pack.

Interests:

Anybody and everything that can be transformed into a pixel.

Contact

Ron Simon
rsimon@paleycenter.org

Most Recent Comments

Thanks Rich for your insight, Now we have Carson and Draper born almost the s...
Read More

As to Don Draper's birthplace, his charactor once noted that we was born in "...
Read More

Thanks for your observation Bob. Matt Weiner has been very scrupulous in maki...
Read More

Archives