August 31, 2010
Mad Men: Clio Meets Emmy
by Ron SimonAs Mad Men nears the middle of its fourth season, the meaning and protocol of industry awards was clearly on creator Matt Weiner's mind. How propitious was that as Don Draper and gang sweated out a fictional ceremony, hoping for Clio recognition for their cinematic Glo-Coat commercial, Weiner and his team were anxious about a possible third consecutive Emmy win for best drama series. I watched Mad Men, with the Emmy broadcast PIP (picture within picture); it was a privileged live moment for experiencing the prophetic intermingling of the real and the fictional.
A major theme of Sunday's "Waldorf Stories" was crediting, who deserves a slice of the awards pie. Copywriter Peggy Olson was sulky throughout the episode, complaining the boy in the nominated commercial was her idea. She wasn't even invited to the ceremony. (We never saw the creation of this "revolutionary" commercial so everyone in the SCDP office has his or her own Rashomonesque perspective.) Senior partner Roger Sterling groused that they don't give awards for what he does, such as hiring the people that get the awards. Flashbacks proved otherwise; wonder boy Don's employment resulted as much by chance as any executive foresight by Roger. Draper personally exulted in triumph, but everyone knew the golden boy was severely tarnished, his creative juices gone dry.
Matt Weiner is no longer the wunderkind of serial drama.
Influential reviewers questioned his current artistic mojo, openly hawking The Good Wife for top honors. Even these tumultuous times can't justify this network push by many members of the critical establishment for more standard TV fare; maybe it is just the time for a new face of quality TV. Early during the telecast, the Academy showed it didn't buy this argument, honoring Mad Men for Outstanding Writing. In his acceptance speech with cowriter Erin Levy, Weiner came off as the anti-Draper, proclaiming he solicits notes from the entire production staff. In marked opposition to his protagonist, he foregrounded the team accepting his individual award.
But at 10:51pm the orbits of Mad Men and the Emmy awards were in total sync, with roles now seemingly reversed. As Peggy castigated a post-bender Don for his plagiaristic professional and private shortcomings, Weiner began his acceptance for the major award of the night, Outstanding Drama. For the group award, he found the "I" in team. He started his remarks rather pompously "So where was I..." (For the TV historians out there, this is a variant of the self-obsessed Jack Paar returning to his series after a prolonged exile.) Ego had begun to take over; and Weiner the writer was proven right, awards do change everything.
Having watched Weiner integrated into my mashed up Mad Men, I couldn't help notice the physical similarities between the creator and the fledgling Danny, who had been confidently hounding Draper for a job at the opening and close of the episode. Beyond the short and balding, perhaps this was the auteur as a young man: gripped with one idea and seeing the past as his own. (How sweet that Danny saw part of his vision in that landmark Volkswagen campaign, the ad referenced many times on the show.) Maybe Weiner is telling us that the hunger for the golden trophy begins here. With even more hardware, let us hope that Mad Men continues to be the cure for common television.

- share: del.icio.us
- Digg this!
- StumbleUpon
Join The Conversation
About
Ron Simon
Curator, Television and Radio
Ron Simon has been a curator at The Paley Center for Media since the early 1980s. He is also an adjunct associate professor at Columbia University, New York University, and Hunter College, where he teaches courses on the history of media. Simon has written for many publications, including The Encyclopedia of Television and Thinking Outside of the Box, as well as serving as host and creative consultant of the CD-ROM Total Television. A member of the editorial board of Television Quarterly, and a judge on the George Foster Peabody committee, Simon has lectured at museums and educational institutions throughout the world. Among the numerous exhibitions he has curated are The Television of Dennis Potter; Witness to History; Jack Benny: The Television and Radio Work; and Worlds Without End: The Art and History of the Soap Opera. He also discovered such lost programs as the live Honeymooners and the only video performance of the Rat Pack.
Interests:Anybody and everything that can be transformed into a pixel.
Contact
Ron Simon
rsimon@paleycenter.org
Most Recent Comments
Thanks so much for your idea, Joel. Yes, Jerry was quite articulate on what ...
Read More
Ron,
I hope the Paley Center will release a CD for the full presentation that...
Read More
Hello Ron:
Wow! What a find.
For years people have said that there is si...
Read More


I like that - watching the past Clio and present Emmy awards at the same time. I like that Mad Men (and intelligent writing) got another Emmy too. Lets hope the notion of good programing rubs off on some of the other cable and network stations a little more.
Bob Morgan, September 10, 2010 at 11:04 am
Thanks Longtimer and Eric for your thoughts. Whatever the reason for the scheduling, it made for a night of provocative television. I like the idea of one show simutaneously commenting on another; but it takes a lot on concentration on the viewer's part. i also like the idea of Peggy getting so frustrated that she forms her own boutique agency. But that would be a few seasons of misery from now. It is also great to hear the names of Bob and Ray and Stan Freberg again. I hope that Mad Men references them again soon.
Ron, September 01, 2010 at 3:38 pm
Not that anyone asked me but:
An idea occured to me for Peggy. At the time of "Mad Men" there were something I think called, "specialty agencies." These were comparatively small advertising agencies that helped firms whose products were constantly placing second or third behind national brands.
One of these was Contadina (spell?) tomato paste. They went to a man named Stan Freberg whose agency created the slogan, "Who put those eight great tomatoes in that itty bitty can?"
These agencies, which included Bob Elliot and Ray Golding's Graybar Advertising.pulled off the very difficult job of making funny commercials the audience remembered without making the product the butt of the joke. They were later followed by the Alka Seltzer commercials. ("I don't nag. Your mother nags." Plip-plop.) People remember the product, and maybe appreciated being given a laugh rather than a hard sell.
Peggy, through a friend, learns about a possible opening for a copy writer at an agency's like Freberg's. The staff is creative and slightly nuts but a lot friendlier than she finds at Sterling Cooper and the creative opportunities are a lot better. But would Peggy take a chance on such an agency because once the clients get to be number one, they tend to move their acccount to one of the bigger national agencies.
Longtimer, September 01, 2010 at 2:28 pm
Eric, September 01, 2010 at 5:29 am