Arthur Smith

Assistant Curator

September 19, 2008


by Arthur Smith

The football-centric sitcom Coach aired on ABC from 1989 to 1997, an impressive and highly profitable run for any series, but, for me, an even more striking aspect of the program is this: I have never heard another living soul ever mention having watched it, or, indeed, refer to it in any context. Hundreds of thousands of airings across the country in syndication, and its impact on popular culture, for all intents and purposes, has been nil.
A whole body of these shows exists in this strange twilight zone of reasonable quality, apparent commercial success, and phantom viewerships. Any Becker fans out there? Can anyone name their top three favorite Cybil episodes? Can anyone name three Cybil episodes? I’ve come to think of these shows as “middlin’”; they’re okay, forgettable, sort of the programming equivalent of end tables. They look fine in the room, but if they disappeared, you might not notice for a while.
I’ve always considered Wings, a sort of Cheers-lite ensemble piece set in a small Alaskan airport, the Ur-middlin’ sitcom. A pleasant time-filler, mechanically producing the familiar set-up/punchline rhythms generations of TV babies have grown up on and respond to with Pavlovian unconscious chuckles. Wings ran for seven years on NBC, and, as with Coach, no one I knew watched it or talked about it; it was just sort of there, inoffensive and unremarkable, like an off-brand of corn flakes sitting neglected on the supermarket shelf next to the dynamically branded likes of Tony the Tiger and Snap!, Crackle!, and Pop!
Then I met Chris.
Chris is a pop culture enthusiast (or “nerd”) like me, and the early days of our friendship were spent sharing passions for television comedies like SCTV, NewsRadio, Alan Partridge, and ... Wings?  Chris loved Wings. Chris had the complete series—seven years’ worth—on VHS, taped from a syndicated run during his college years. I was utterly flummoxed. No one loved Wings. You watched Wings by accident, when you were home sick and too out of it to change the channel. You did not obsessively tape two airings every day, then spend countless hours transferring these tapes to DVD on your computer. I began to wonder if Chris had body parts in hidden in his freezer. This was just creepy. I mean…Wings?!
I had to ask him about it. I really liked the guy, and didn’t want Crystal Bernard to come between us. He explained that the central relationship on the show—the fractious rivalry between brother pilots played by Steven Weber and Timothy Daly—so reminded him of his relationship with his own brother that he was drawn into the world of the show and became increasingly charmed by it, gradually becoming equally involved in each of the other characters’ quirks and ambitions. Wings became a little oasis of family feeling for him, far from home in an unfamiliar place, and so he loved it.
Television is sometimes called the electronic hearth, and maybe that’s as noble a function for the machine as being a disseminator of news or an organ for spectacular entertainment or occasional art. It warms us. It’s a comfort. As a child, I loved a middlin’ show. It was called Angie, and it starred Donna Pescow and Robert Hayes as an odd couple struggling with a new marriage. It wasn’t great. I watched it because Angie’s younger sister, played by Mary Hartman, Mary Hartman vet Debralee Scott was sort of a goofball, and reminded me of my favorite aunt, who lived across the country and who I missed very much. I also liked a bit of business in the opening credits involving some balloons. It doesn’t take much, I guess.
Any middlin’ show lovers out there? Let us know!

  • "Two and a Half Men" would be this generation's top "middler," yeah?

    wexlerglazer, December 11, 2008 at 1:45 pm

  • Woah, Arthur. I'm a huge Wings fan. And I can tell you it's not set in Alaska--that's Northern Exposure--but Cape Cod. What an all-star cast: besides Daly and Weber, you've got Tony Shahloub and Thomas Hayden Church. And, I like Coached too, mostly for Nelson. I found his character hilarious. And I though the whole college football setting very refreshing.

    M.A.Peel, September 30, 2008 at 5:41 pm

  • King of Queens is a show that ran for 9 seasons. I have never heard anyone mention watching it. I watched once or twice to see Jerry Stiller. If DNA from John Goodman’s character on Rosanne and Ed O’Neill’s character on Married With Children were selected for just physical traits and all comedic sensibilities were screened out, it would spawn KOQ’s Kevin James.

    Nicole, September 26, 2008 at 10:19 am

  • Hey Arthur, I also loved Angie! "Let the time flow, let the love grow..." Great theme! and don't forget Doris Roberts. But I must take umbrage with your placement of Wings into this "Middlin" category. I have to stand by my contention that this show deserves a place among the greatest achievements of mankind. Not only does it perfectly capture the loving sibling rivalry of my relationship with my brother, but it says so much more about humanity. How to balance where we come from and where we are headed. How to measure personal success. The responsibilities and benefits of belonging to a family unit. True love and trust, betrayal and forgiveness, lust, fear, and madness. I believe that were Thorton Wilder alive today, he would put a copy of the full run of Wings into his Our Town time capsule. It truly captures the beauty of a life filled with faith, family, and a sense of humor. Oops, gotta run. I need to go check on my freezer. -Chris

    Chris, September 23, 2008 at 12:13 pm


Arthur Smith

Assistant Curator


Arthur Smith worked in a film archive and failed to earn a living as a professional musician before joining the Paley Center in 1997. He’s not bitter, but has unhealthy fixations on tweedy clothing and Marvel comics.


60s Pop Music, Comedy, Comic Books, Great and/or Terrible Movies, and Exotic Brunettes


Arthur Smith

Most Recent Comments

I loved the show Sisters when I was a kid and still do whenever I am able to...
Read More

Eightball has already been adapted to film, twice and by the same director! T...
Read More

Remember when people used only original music to sell their product or point ...
Read More